Posts Tagged ‘Delivery’

Pearls

Thursday, December 3rd, 2009 by virginia

I had a rare craving for sesame chicken and other standard Chinese food fare so I did a quick search on seamlessweb and found Pearls, a restaurant that served both basic dishes and Chinese specialties at super cheap prices.

Just looking over the menu, it’s obvious that the restaurant caters to the work crowd. The combination specials include a choice of entrée, rice, an egg roll or spring roll, and soup. These specials run for under $7 at lunch time and for under $8 at dinner time. As a bonus, you get 20% off if you order through seamlessweb, making it an even better bargain. While the entrée sizes aren’t as large as you would normally get if you ordered a la carte, they’re still sizeable and enough for two people to share.

Josh and I decided to split three dinner combination specials, knowing full well that it would be too much food and I could take some leftovers for lunch the next few days. With the combinations, we decided to try a variety of the side options offered. We got two egg rolls and a spring roll so we could taste the difference.

The egg rolls were fantastic – hot, crunchy, packed with well-seasoned veggies. They were probably some of the best egg rolls that we’ve ever received in a delivery. The spring roll was disappointing, as the outer shell was soggy and very greasy. The filling was similar to the egg roll filling but I couldn’t get over the oiliness of the spring roll skin.

Egg rolls and a spring roll on the bottom

Egg rolls and a spring roll on the bottom

For the soup, we selected both hot and sour and wonton. The hot and sour soup was more sour than hot, but it had a strong pepper flavor that tickled the back of our throats. The soup is chock full of mushrooms, bamboo shoots, and other fillings, making it very rich and hearty. I could eat a container of this soup as a meal and be really stuffed.

Peppery hot and sour soup

Peppery hot and sour soup

The wonton soup was a chicken broth with scallions and a few pieces of wontons floating about. The wontons were just ok, a bit heavy on the skin and the filling was a bit too dense, but the soup was simple and light, a nice contrast to the rest of the meal.

Wonton soup

Wonton soup

For our entrees, we selected the sesame chicken, mapo tofu, and curry chicken. The sesame chicken was a pretty good version, with a still somewhat crispy outer coating and a not too overly sweet or gloppy sauce. It came with crunchy pieces of broccoli and definitely satisfied my sesame chicken craving.

Sesame chicken

Sesame chicken

The mapo tofu was also decent, though not as spicy as I had hoped it would be. The tofu was a bit firmer than in most other versions, which I liked, but the sauce was too tame and a bit too thick in texture. I liked the little bits of pork mixed throughout, but overall the dish could have used some more seasoning and spice.

Mapo tofu

Mapo tofu

The curry chicken was a disappointment as I was hoping for curry chicken similar to what you would find in a Malaysian or Singaporean restaurant – bone in chicken stewed in a mélange of spices and a tiny bit of coconut milk until it was falling off the bone. This curry chicken was thin slices of white meat coated in a sauce that tasted of regular off the shelf yellow curry powder. It wasn’t awful; it was just really boring. Plus there were too many onion slices mixed throughout, and most of them were still kind of raw and provided a very harsh bite to the dish. I definitely wouldn’t order this dish again.

Curry chicken with almost raw onions

Curry chicken with too many almost raw onions

Overall I thought the food at Pearls was actually pretty good. We did order uncomplicated standard dishes though, and not any of the more “authentic” Chinese options. The food came fast, it was still hot, and everything was packaged nicely, making it a great delivery option for whether you’re at work or at home. Prices for the combination specials are very reasonable and you get a ton of food. I would absolutely order from here again the next time I get a sesame chicken craving, and I wouldn’t mind trying some of the more interesting dishes from the a la carte menu.

Pearls
732 7th Ave. between 48th and 49th St.
New York, NY

Victor’s Pizza

Monday, November 30th, 2009 by virginia

When Josh and I are testing out pizza on our quest for the go-to delivery place, we compare them to our golden standard, Victor’s Pizza in Teaneck, NJ. This is the pizza that we grew up eating so maybe that’s why we hold it up on a pedestal, but even when we’re home visiting our parents on weekends, we’ll stop by for a slice or a small pie and it’s always as good as we remember.

But our quest is about delivery pizza, so one Saturday when we were in NJ we placed a delivery order for a large cheese pizza, a chicken parm hero, and an eggplant parm hero. We always ask for our pie to be “well done” so that the crust is golden and the cheese is brown and bubbly.

Large cheese pizza "well done"

Large cheese pizza "well done"

As usual, Victor’s delivered the perfect pie, with a crust that’s crispy on the outside and nicely chewy in the middle. The crust has a nice developed flavor but doesn’t taste too floury or yeasty. The sauce to cheese to crust ratio is also spot on, and there’s a nice saltiness to the cheese that complements the sweet tomato sauce.

Underside shot

Underside shot

The chicken parmesan hero is packed with lots of breaded chicken but it usually needs some extra toasting in the oven to crisp up the bread a little bit and melt the cheese more. I wish the “well done” philosophy also applied to their sandwiches. Still, it’s a substantial and pretty tasty version of the hero.

Cheesy chicken parm hero

Cheesy chicken parm hero

I’m not the hugest fan of eggplant parm heroes, as I think they’re usually seedy and slimey, but Victor’s actually makes a pretty good rendition that almost makes you forget there’s no meat. The eggplant in the sandwich is more thickly sliced and breaded, which makes it seem much heartier.

Meaty eggplant parm hero

Meaty eggplant parm hero

I don’t know exactly what it is about Victor’s Pizza that makes it so delicious, but pizza preference is always a personal taste. The thing about Victor’s is its consistency. It delivers a basic, classic pie that’s always very well prepared every single time we get it. We haven’t found that consistency with any of the places we’ve ordered from in the city. Every place that showed potential disappointed us the second time around. So while our quest for our go-to pizza place continues, I can take comfort in knowing that if I’m truly craving a solid standard pizzeria style pizza, I can just head to Victor’s the next time we’re in NJ.

Victor’s Pizza
540 Cedar Lane
Teaneck, NJ

Baluchi’s

Saturday, November 28th, 2009 by virginia

Josh and I both love Indian food but it’s not something we eat too often, as most of our family members don’t enjoy it as much as we do. When we do have Indian food, we usually get it delivered for dinner. We’ve tried a few places in our neighborhood but our standard go-to place is Baluchi’s. There are branches all over the city, and even when we lived downtown we would order in from the one in Tribeca or visit it during lunchtime when everything is 50% off (even on weekends). I can’t really vouch for the authenticity, but the food is consistently good and their delivery/takeout prix fixe menu is really a great value.

For $14.95, you can select an appetizer and an entrée from a decently long list of offerings. It doesn’t include everything on the regular a la carte menu but there’s a nice variety and most “standard” Indian dishes are available. The prix fixe also includes basmati rice, a piece of naan bread, cucumber raita, and mango chutney. When you consider that most chicken/lamb curries already start out at $13.95/$14.95 when ordered a la carte, and appetizers start out at $6.95, this prix fixe is an incredible deal.

One night when Josh and I had a craving for some Indian curry, we placed a delivery order using Baluchi’s easy online system. We decided to get two prix fixes, one with samosas and lamb rogan josh, and another with aloo papri and chicken korma. Usually we get two orders of samosas, as they are our favorite appetizer and Baluchi’s has one of the better versions that we’ve had. The skin is thinner and usually still somewhat crispy even after being delivered. The filling of potato and peas is soft and flavored with curry powder. They top the samosas with chickpeas, and then drizzle on a tasty green sauce and a tamarind sauce. There is a mélange of textures and flavors that all really work well together. It’s salty, sweet, and a little bit sour.

Samosas

Samosas

This time we decided to try a new appetizer in addition the samosas. We opted for the aloo papri, which is described on the menu as a snack with potatoes, chickpeas, and yogurt. While it did have a messy pile of chickpeas, yogurt, tamarind, and green sauce, there were no potatoes to be found. There were little soggy crisps mixed throughout though that I think were fried lentil dumplings, like in papri chaat. I was a bit disappointed with this dish as it had similar ingredients to samosas, minus the potatoes, but less flavor overall and it was very mushy in texture.

Aloo papri and the case of the missing potatoes

Aloo papri, though no potatoes

Lamb rogan josh is my favorite Indian dish, and this is one of the best versions that I’ve had. There are huge chunks of tender gamey lamb stewed with tomatoes in a cardamom sauce. The dish is spicy in a flavorful way but doesn’t have any heat to it. I like to wrap pieces of the lamb in some naan bread and dip it in the curry sauce, then in the raita. The yogurt mellows out some of the spice and makes the curry a bit creamier.

Lamb rogan josh

Lamb rogan josh

Chicken korma is Josh’s favorite Indian dish, though I find Baluchi’s version to be a bit too creamy in flavor. The curry is made from an almond cream sauce and the pieces of chicken are mixed with fruit and nuts, giving it a nice sweetness. Though it’s a very mild curry, it’s also very thick and rich so I can’t eat too much of it. I usually end up mixing some of the korma curry with the lamb rogan josh curry to create a sort of creamy tomato-y curry sauce that I mix together with the basmati rice.

Chicken korma

Chicken korma

The basmati rice is mixed with visible pieces of dried spices, which I pick out before eating as biting into a clove or cardamom pod gives you kind of a shock. The flavors of the spices still remain with rice though, making it very fragrant. The naan bread is large and fluffy and always comes wrapped in a piece of aluminum foil so it stays warm. I really like that they give you both rice and naan, since it’s hard to choose between the two.

A little taste of everything with a big fluffy piece of naan

A little taste of everything with a big fluffy piece of naan

As I said earlier, while I don’t know how authentic the food is, Baluchi’s is still our go-to Indian restaurant. Now that we live on the upper west side, we order in from the 56th St. branch, but I’ve found the food to be pretty consistent between different branches. When we get delivery, we always get the prix fixe as it’s a bargain compared to other places. The portions are as large or larger than other restaurant deliveries, and the food is always tasty and flavorful. I highly recommend checking it out the next time you have a craving for Indian food.

Baluchi’s (multiple locations)
240 West 56th St. between 8th Ave. and Broadway
New York, NY

Sacco Pizza

Sunday, November 22nd, 2009 by virginia

Josh and I are still on our quest to find the best go-to pizza place for delivery. We eat pizza a lot, as you can probably tell, but we still haven’t found a place that we can both agree on. While walking home from a bar on 9th Ave. one evening, we passed Sacco Pizza, a tiny hole-in-the-wall joint where a lot of people were lined up for a late night snack. The pizza that was being dished out look and smelled pretty good so we picked up a menu and made a mental note to order from there the next time.

When our next hankering for pizza rolled around a few days later, we placed an order for an extra large cheese pie and something called gaucho pie. We had no idea what gaucho pie was but it turned out to be kind of like a beef empanada with a pizza dough crust. Or it could be a calzone stuffed with ground beef but no cheese or sauce.

Gaucho pie

Gaucho pie

It was an interesting concept but we weren’t huge fans of the beef filling, as it was kind of greasy and didn’t have much meaty flavor. It was also overly salty, and I wish they gave us some tomato sauce to dip with. I was glad to have tried it but would probably not order it again.

Gaucho pie innards

Gaucho pie innards

The pizza was pretty good, though the crust was on the thinner side. Again, this is where Josh and I disagree. He likes super thin crispy crusts and I like crusts with a bit of a chew on the inside.

Pizza with a relatively thin crust

Pizza with a relatively thin crust

Sacco’s crust was thin but it still had some chew. It was nicely browned and had a good flavor to it.

Underside shot

Underside shot

It also had a good sauce to cheese ratio, and we both thought it was a very well done pie.

Good cheese to sauce to crust ratio

Good cheese to sauce to crust ratio

Overall I think we would probably order from Sacco again. We didn’t try out their heroes, which is one of our tests of a go-to pizza place, so next time we’ll have to make sure we test those as well. We’ll pass on the gaucho pie though.

Sacco Pizza
819 9th Ave. at 54th St.
New York, NY

Lucky Sunday

Saturday, August 29th, 2009 by virginia

After our last peking duck debacle, Josh was still craving the crispy/fatty goodness of properly prepared peking duck so we went through the pile of menus that have been slipped underneath our door and found the one for Lucky Sunday. We placed our standard Chinese food order over the phone and our food arrived a short while later.

The peking duck visibly just looked better than the one from Empire Szechuan Kyoto. It didn’t look like it had been deep fried, and the skin was crispy and glistening. The pancakes they brought us were still warm and pliable, and they also provided a big pile of scallions and cucumbers to wrap with the duck. The duck itself was moist and fatty in a good way. The only thing I didn’t really like was the hoisin sauce, which tasted more bbq-y than what I’m used to.

Peking duck and accessories

Peking duck and accessories

We also got two egg rolls that were still warm and crispy, though the filling was kind of bland. I had to use a lot of duck sauce to get any kind of flavor, which was pretty disappointing. I probably wouldn’t order egg rolls from there again.

Bland egg rolls

Bland egg rolls

The cold sesame noodles were also lacking in flavor and seasoning. They didn’t put enough sesame sauce on it so the whole thing was really dry and bland. There was also a weird hint of coffee taste to the sauce, which I found kind of unpleasant. I was not a fan of this dish.

Bland sesame noodles

Bland sesame noodles

On the positive side, the sesame chicken was much more enjoyable. The chicken was a bit fattier than normal but that helped keep the pieces more moist and tender. Usually sesame chicken is made with all white meat chicken and it tends to get too dry. The breading ended up being a bit soggy but the sauce was sticky and gooey without being overly sweet, and was perfect for spooning over rice. They also included pieces of broccoli with the chicken, which were a nice crunchy addition.

Sesame chicken with broccoli

Sesame chicken with broccoli

Overall the food from Lucky Sunday was kind of a mixed bag but they fared better in the items that mattered more to us – the peking duck and the sesame chicken. While they weren’t the best versions that we’ve ever had, they were pretty good, especially since these dishes don’t usually hold up well when factoring in delivery time. I would probably order in from here again, though next time I would stay away from the appetizers.

Lucky Sunday
858 8th Ave. between 51st and 52nd St.
New York, NY

Fat Sal’s Pizza

Saturday, August 15th, 2009 by virginia

So I have a dilemma that I thought I’d put forth to you, the readers. If you had some of the best pizza you’ve ever eaten, but it showed up to your door looking like this, would you order from this pizza place again?

This is what our pizza looked like when it arrived - no joke

This is what our pizza looked like when it arrived - no joke

Thus is my experience with Fat Sal’s Pizza. In the interest of full disclosure, I may have caused our pizza to arrive looking like that, although I still don’t know if that makes it acceptable.

We were continuing our quest for our go-to pizza place and decided to try out Fat Sal’s on 10th Ave. I placed our order on delivery.com, a website that we’ve used before, and somehow our address was messed up. I don’t really know how that happened, but I must’ve mistyped it at some point. We do have an account and I just logged into it, so I didn’t check the address before I submitted our order. We’ve ordered using that account previously without any problems so I wasn’t aware there was an issue.

Nevertheless, when the pizzeria called us up to verify our address, Josh apologized profusely about the mistake. So the deliveryman had traveled four blocks out of his way, and we honestly felt badly about it. We planned to make it up to him in the tip, and we would have completely understood if it took a long time for the delivery to come or if our food was cold. We were definitely in the wrong, and we knew that.

We didn’t open up the pizza box until after the deliveryman took his tip and left, and now we understand his haste in getting out of our apartment. Lets see that picture again, close up this time, and from a different angle.

Different angle, but still just as messed up

Different angle, but still just as messed up

So what happened? Did he purposely turn our pizza box sideways in retaliation for sending him to the wrong address? But he must have realized it was an honest mistake, not a vicious sabotage to send him four blocks in the wrong direction. And why didn’t he think that we would be apologetic and try to make it up to him with a larger tip? It doesn’t make sense. I can understand that if we shafted him on the tip, then the next time we ordered he would do that to our pizza. So maybe he dropped the pizza by accident? The pizza was in such a state that there’s no way he didn’t realize he had dropped it or tilted it severely. It was completely mangled and glued together at the side of the box.

I managed to pry most of the pieces apart, but not without losing a lot of cheese in the process. Surprisingly, the pizza was still warm. The crust was pretty floppy though, and I don’t know if that was a result of the treatment or if that’s how the crust normally is. It wasn’t super thin nor was it too thick. The outer crust was actually really good, with a bit of crispiness on the outside and a nice chewy texture on the inside. It reminded me of a really good baguette. Despite the floppiness, I really did enjoy the pizza and thought it was the best that I’ve had yet on our quest.

Mangled slice with unintentional underside shot

Mangled slice with unintentional underside shot

The chicken parmesan hero was also really good. It was huge and served on a nice crispy roll. There was a lot of chicken but could have used a bit more cheese. Still, it was pretty tasty.

Chicken parm hero

Chicken parm hero

The garlic knots were standard but they had a nice texture to them and good garlic coverage.

Garlic knots

Decent garlic knots

So what’s the verdict? I don’t know. I really enjoyed the pizza and would have definitely ordered from here again had the pizza not arrived in such a disastrous state. But I do feel bad about the address mix-up, so maybe I was partially to blame. Still, do I want to order from a place that would either be so vindictive or so careless? It’s a tough call. I’m going to work my way through the other pizzerias in the area, and if I don’t find anything better, maybe I’ll consider ordering from here again. If you were in my shoes, what would you do?

Fat Sal’s Pizza (multiple locations)
730 10th Ave. at 50th St.
New York, NY

New Taco Express

Friday, August 14th, 2009 by virginia

New Taco Express is one of those super cheap Mexican food joints that is neither authentic nor outstanding but offers quick and decent food at great prices. It’s almost identical to the Fresco Tortilla restaurants that are available all over the city. While the food isn’t spectacular, it’s reliable and you always know what to expect; it’s kind of like fast food in that regard.

I usually get the same order at these places – a combination plate with chicken, and tex-mex chili on a flour tortilla. The combination plates are huge and come with chicken, rice, beans (black or pinto, your choice), lettuce, tomato, and two flour tortillas. The flour tortillas are my favorite – they’re homemade and thicker and doughier than supermarket tortillas. They have a nice mild flavor and a pleasant chewy texture. The chicken that comes with the combination plate is an ample portion and more than enough to fill the two tortillas. I always mix the rest with the rice and beans and eat it with a fork.

Chicken combination platter

Chicken combination plate

The tex-mex chili is pretty standard but I think of it as comfort food. It’s usually a bit oily but this version was actually not that bad. And it just gives me an excuse to eat another flour tortilla.

Chili on a flour tortilla

Chili on a flour tortilla

Josh got a combination plate with steak and chicken. Again, it’s a lot of food, and the meats are decently tender and nicely seasoned. At less than $6 a plate, you really can’t go wrong.

Chicken and steak combination plate

Chicken and steak combination plate

If you accept New Taco Express for what it is, the food really isn’t terrible. It’s not gourmet, and not even really Mexican, but the food is cheap, filling, and dependable. When it’s late at night and you’re at a loss for what to have for dinner, it fits the bill. The delivery comes super quick and the food is always hot. The two of us can eat for less than $15, and I’ll still have leftovers for lunch.

New Taco Express
857 9th Ave. between 55th and 56th St.
New York, NY

Empire Szechuan Kyoto

Wednesday, August 5th, 2009 by virginia

Josh had a hankering for peking duck and we hadn’t ordered in any Chinese food yet from our new place, so I did a find-a-food search on menupages. There weren’t very many options that came up in the search, which I was kind of surprised about. Not knowing too much about each of the restaurants, we ended up picking the place with the best overall rating that was reasonably priced.

The delivery came pretty quickly the hot food was still warm in their containers, so bonus points for that. When I popped open the lid on the container that held our half order of peking duck, however, my face fell immediately. The duck was deep fried, not roasted. And deep fried to a dry, chewy texture. There was no seasoning or flavoring on the skin, meaning it wasn’t basted in whatever sauce that normally shellacs the skin of a peking duck. The skin was also totally tough and fried to a point that it was not crispy and was actually soggy with oil. This poor over-fried dried out bird bore absolutely no resemblance to peking duck.

Deep fried and dried out peking duck

Deep fried and dried out peking duck

I had placed the delivery on seamlessweb and asked in the special instructions section for them to bring six pancakes for the peking duck, since the normal order contains five pancakes. I guess they didn’t take note of my special request, because only five pancakes arrived. At least they didn’t charge me extra for the missing pancake. They did bring a ton of shredded scallions and julienned cucumbers for the duck though, which was nice. After smearing a pancake with a ton of hoisin sauce and adding a large handful of scallions/cucumbers, I could almost pretend that the duck was moist and had some flavor.

The extra scallions and cucumbers also came in handy for our order of cold noodles with sesame sauce. The sesame sauce was really thick, much thicker than I’m used to, but the noodles were also a thicker variety so they pared well. Adding the fresh vegetables provided a crispy textural contrast to an otherwise soft dish. I enjoyed the noodles, but they weren’t spectacular. It’s hard to mess up this dish.

Cold sesame noodles

Cold sesame noodles

We also ordered two egg rolls, but they called us and told us they only had one left. Umm, ok? I guess they pre-make these and only have a certain number on hand. On the bill they brought with the delivery order, they only charged one egg roll, but since we paid through seamlessweb, and that order had two egg rolls, I don’t know if it was fixed before it was charged to our credit card. I’ll have to check our statement later and see. The egg roll itself was pretty good, as it had chunks of pork and shrimp in it, and it was still hot and crispy. I was disappointed they didn’t have two because I didn’t want to share with Josh!

Pretty decent egg roll

Pretty decent egg roll

We also got an order of sesame chicken, which was a bit dry. The chicken pieces seemed really bready and not very meaty. The sauce was pretty standard, more sweet than tangy, but they did sprinkle a lot of sesame seeds on top, which I liked. They also brought fried rice noodles on the side to put on top, and while in theory that was smart, so it wouldn’t get soggy if it were pre-mixed with the chicken, but the steam in the container made them soggy anyway. It was kind of like putting pieces of chewy styrofoam on top. Not very appetizing.

Sesame chicken

Sesame chicken

We don’t crave Chinese food often (Josh does more than I do, since I grew up eating Chinese food basically every day) but it would be nice to have a standby place to order in from. I miss our place downtown, Empire Szechuan Village (it doesn’t seem to be related to Empire Szechuan Kyoto), as their peking duck was fabulous and cooked right, not deep fried. We’ll have to keep looking for a new place to try out, or else Josh will have to start making is own peking duck whenever he craves it. His version is pretty spectacular but it’s very time consuming.

Unfortunately, we don’t have too many Chinese food options in our delivery area, and even less that serve peking duck. The food we got from Empire Szechuan Kyoto was pretty disappointing though. The only thing I really enjoyed was the egg roll, but I can get egg rolls anywhere. Our main dishes, the peking duck and the sesame chicken, both failed on many levels. I don’t think we’ll be ordering in from here again.

Empire Szechuan Kyoto
193 Columbus Ave. between 68th and 69th St.
New York, NY

Big Nick’s Pizza & Burger Joint

Sunday, August 2nd, 2009 by virginia

Since Amadeus Pizza was such a bust the last time, Josh and I continued on our quest for finding the best go-to pizza place. This time I perused delivery.com and found a 20% coupon for Big Nick’s Pizza & Burger Joint. We got our standard order of a large cheese pie, a chicken parm hero, and garlic knots.

Everything arrived hot, which was a huge plus. The pizza looked a little disheveled as a result of being transported, but it was appropriately browned, not like the pale pie Amadeus sent us.

A slight disheveled pizza

A slight disheveled pizza

Josh and I had differing opinions about Big Nick’s pizza. He thought the crust was too thick, a big no-no for him. I thought the crust was a bit thicker than most but it was far from a pan pizza, and it had a nice crunch to it. I also really liked the sauce, which had a lot of herbs mixed into it that gave it more flavor. While not amazing, I thought this was a pretty decent pie.

Underside shot

Underside shot

The chicken parm on the other hand was pretty gross. I don’t know if they served it on a whole wheat roll (which was an option, but I didn’t select that option) but the bread just tasted weird. It definitely had a wheat flavor and was way too sweet. The flavor of the roll clashed with the flavors of the chicken parmesan. They also wrapped the sandwich in a way that all the cheese stuck to the foil and pulled off when I tried to open it. It was just a bad version overall.

A pretty bad chicken parm sandwich

A pretty bad chicken parm sandwich

The garlic knots were also just eh. They were a bit cold and stale and didn’t pack much of a garlic punch.

Just ok garlic knots

Just ok garlic knots

The overall verdict for Big Nick’s Pizza? Thumbs down. While I enjoyed the pizza, it was not so spectacular that it overcame the faults of its chicken parm hero and garlic knots. Josh didn’t like the pizza because he hated the thicker crust, so basically this was a no-brainer. However, we didn’t try the “Burger Joint” part of Big Nick’s, so maybe we’ll stop by there one day to check out their massive list of burger offerings. But as for the pizza, our quest continues and we’ll be ordering in from a new place next time.

Big Nick’s Pizza & Burger Joint
70 West 71st St. at Columbus Ave.
New York, NY

Hayashi Ya

Thursday, July 23rd, 2009 by virginia

We had yet another Japanese menu slipped under our door, and since we were craving sushi we decided to give it a shot. There were lots of items to choose from and prices seemed pretty reasonable. We placed our order over the phone, and it arrived about 35 minutes later, which isn’t too shabby. Unfortunately, most of our hot food arrived pretty cold.

We started out with miso soups that had lots of tofu and seaweed in it, but it was lukewarm at best. The miso was mild in flavor, which I liked, since a lot of versions tend to be too salty. I supposed I could have nuked it in the microwave to warm it up a bit, but I was hungry and too lazy.

Lukewarm miso soups

Lukewarm miso soups

We also ordered a chicken katsu combination, which came with rice, a small salad, and side dish of our choice. We opted for shrimp shumai, which were clearly the pre-made frozen kind and were totally ice cold in the middle. Too bad, because they were actually really tasty, but I guess I can just go to an Asian supermarket and pick these up for myself and warm them up correctly. The chicken katsu was a bit hotter, but not by much, and it was pretty soggy and greasy. I can forgive the soggy, since it has to be delivered in a covered container, but the greasiness was kind of gross, as the breading just tasted oily. Not pleasant. And also boo for the prepackaged katsu sauce. The salad was just chopped up lettuce and one tomato slice, but I did like the ginger dressing.

Chicken katsu, shrimp shumai, green salad with ginger dressing

Chicken katsu, shrimp shumai, green salad with ginger dressing

We ordered a variety of our favorite standard sushi rolls, which included a tuna roll, a salmon avocado roll, a spicy tuna roll, and a yellowtail and scallion roll. I tend not to go for special rolls since all the fish just kind of gets mixed together and it’s hard to taste each component individually. I enjoyed the spicy tuna roll, which was not too mayo-y tasting, and the yellowtail and scallion roll, since yellowtail is my favorite fish. The tuna in the tuna roll was kind of stringy though, and the salmon was way too fishy, which is kind of scary. I also thought the sushi rice was a tad too sweet for my taste.

Spicy tuna roll, salmon avocado roll, tuna roll, and yellowtail scallion roll

Spicy tuna roll, salmon avocado roll, tuna roll, and yellowtail scallion roll

Overall I thought the food from Hayashi Ya was pretty bad. The only thing that I really liked was the miso soup, but I can pretty much get that anywhere or have Josh make it. I didn’t enjoy their greasy chicken katsu at all, and the sushi was obviously not the freshest. Even though prices are pretty cheap, sushi is not something that you would want to trade quality for just to save a few pennies. And there are plenty of other restaurants that offer cheap prices, like Oyishi, and still provide pretty decent fish. I will definitely not be ordering in from here again.

Hiyashi Ya
857 9th Ave. between 55th and 56th St.
New York, NY