Archive for the ‘Restaurants’ Category

A Perfect Saturday (Lan Zhou Hand Pulled Noodles, Paris Sandwich, Di Palo’s, Lansdowne Road, Famous 53rd Street Halal Cart)

Saturday, May 23rd, 2009 by virginia

When Josh and I lived downtown, we would walk over to Chinatown almost every weekend. It was a bit of a hike but that just gave us an excuse to eat more, since we figured that we’d at least be walking off some of the calories we consumed. Some days we spent trying to find the best soup dumplings and other days we would navigate through the hustle and bustle of the steam carts at dim sum. After our meals, we would always wander through the fruit/vegetable markets and fish stalls and pick up some fresh groceries for the rest of the week. Our treks to Chinatown will always hold a special place in my heart, as it is on the way home from one of these trips that Josh proposed to me, on the steps in front of the Federal court house.

But I digress; this is a food blog after all! So at lunchtime on Saturday, we headed downtown with Claire and Sean, who are staying with us for the weekend, to introduce them to some of our favorite Chinatown foods.

Lan Zhou Hand Pulled Noodles

We started out with hand pulled noodles at Lan Zhou on East Broadway. I know hand pulled noodles have been blogged to death in the last few months, but they are definitely worth talking about. Josh and I have tried Super Taste and Sheng Weng, but we always come back to Lan Zhou because of their tastier broth. We got seats along the wall right next to the noodle maker and proceeded to watch him intently for 10 minutes while we waited for our soups. We’ve seen him make the noodles a hundred times, yet we still can’t grasp how it’s done. It’s simply amazing to see him take a ball of dough, bang it against the table a few times, twist his hands around, and somehow he always winds up with perfectly formed strands of noodles.

Hand pulling noodle man

Hand pulling noodle man

Claire and Sean shared a bowl of beef noodles, while Josh and I opted for the beef brisket noodles (both $4.50 each). The broths are similar – deep, rich and peppery – but the beef brisket is fattier and chewier, which I like better.

Noodle soup with beef brisket

Noodle soup with beef brisket

The noodles here are just perfect – tender yet chewy. They’re thinner than I generally like, but they still have a lot of spring and bite to them.

Yummy yummy noodles

Yummy yummy noodles

We also shared a large order of pan-fried dumplings (12/$3.00). Thin-skinned, crispy, hot and greasy, topped with soy sauce and Sriracha, these are just perfect. Josh and I currently have several bags of frozen dumplings from Lan Zhou in our freezer. They’re perfect for days when we’re just too lazy to cook. You can just pan fry them or boil them straight from the freezer – no need to defrost.

Yummy yummy dumplings

Yummy yummy dumplings

We love this place because you get to watch the noodles and dumplings made right in front of you, and a few minutes later, you’re digging into a steaming bowl or sizzling plate of that same stuff. It just doesn’t get better than that.

Woman hand making rows upon rows of dumplings

Woman hand making rows upon rows of dumplings

We had planned to stop at Prosperity Dumpling on our way to the more touristy side of Chinatown but decided to bypass it so that we could save room for our next stop, Banh Mi Saigon Bakery. Unfortunately, due to the recent amount of press that banh mis have received, the line was almost out the door of the tiny shop. It’s really quite a change from when we used to go and the place would be empty so you could sit on the boxes along the side wall and eat your banh mi right there. Instead of waiting on the ridiculously long line, we headed across the street and down the block to Paris Sandwich, which was almost barren in comparison.

Paris Sandwich

DSCN8167

There was no wait to order two grilled pork ban mis, and we nabbed a table in the back to eat our freshly made sandwiches. The seating area is the only advantage of Paris Sandwich, as you can have your sandwich made to order and eat it right away. The bread, however, while super light and crispy, is pretty tasteless. The grilled pork is tender and the vegetables are fresh but there isn’t enough filling overall. I prefer Banh Mi Saigon Bakery handily over Paris Sandwich, and even if the sandwich is pre-made or if it gets soggy on the way home, I just pop it in the oven for a few minutes and the bread crisps right back up. The filling is ample and the pickled vegetables are perfectly tangy and crunchy. Regardless, the banh mis at Paris Sandwich made for a refreshing “snack,” as we were still pretty full from the hand pulled noodles and dumplings.

Grilled pork banh mi

Grilled pork banh mi

Di Palo’s Fine Foods

DSCN8168

The next stop on our tour was Di Palo’s to pick up some supplies for our planned picnic in Central Park during the afternoon. We got two loaves of excellent Sullivan Street Bakery bread, a one-pound ball of fresh mozzarella ($6.99/lb) and, most exciting of all, a ball of burrata ($7.99). A friend told us about it and we’ve been itching to try it ever since, so this was the perfect time. We picked up some white wine and headed back uptown to meet up with another friend for our picnic.

After debating whether we could get away with drinking the wine in the park, however, we ultimately decided to bring some chairs and a table up to our roof deck and enjoy the outdoors without the hassle. It turned out to be the perfect plan. The weather was just right – warm, not too sunny, with a nice breeze – and the view from our roof is spectacular. It’s basically a 360 degree view of the whole city; we can see all the way down to the Statue of Liberty to the south, the Hudson to the west, all the way up to the GWB to the north, and all of Central Park to the east. Really really stunning.

View of Central Park from our roof deck

View of Central Park from our roof deck

Southern view

Southern view

Northwestern view

Northwestern view

Southeastern view

Southeastern view

Ok back to food. We supplemented our supplies from Di Palo’s with some prosciutto, genoa salami and more fresh mozzarella that our other friend brought in from a deli in Hoboken. We also had some prosciutto and manchego cheese that Josh got from the supermarket nearby, as well as ripe tomatoes on the vine, and some fresh basil from our windowsill planter. It really was quite the spread.

Meats, breads and produce

Meats, breads and produce

Selection of cheeses

Selection of cheeses

The highly anticipated burrata did not disappoint. The smooth exterior of the ball was broken open to reveal the creamy innards, which we spread on the bread with a knife, like ricotta.

Burrata innards

Burrata innards

Creamy and delicious

Creamy and delicious

We tried all the different combinations of the mozzarellas and the prosciuttos, and ate slices of manchego cheese wrapped with salami.

Prosciutto, mozzarella, fresh basil and tomato on Sullivan St. bread

Prosciutto, mozzarella, fresh basil and tomato on Sullivan St. bread

Salami and mozzarella

Salami and mozzarella

We ate until we could eat no more, and there were still tons left over. We spent the next few hours eating, drinking and chatting, and only headed back inside when the sun went down and it got too cold up on the roof. Then we proceeded to eat and drink some more, moving on to strawberries and scotch.

Lansdowne Road

Later in the evening, we headed out for a reunion of sorts at Lansdowne Road (Claire and Sean used to live in NYC and still have tons of friends here). Claire had called ahead to reserve several tables in the back room, and we worked our way through several beer bongs of Magic Hat #9 (my favorite beer), Stone IPA and Blue Moon.

Mmmmmm beer

Mmmmmm beer

Famous 53rd Street Halal Cart

Afterward, Claire and I stumbled our way home (bathroom emergency!) while Sean and Josh headed to 53rd St. and 6th Ave. to get some streetcart food from the Famous Halal cart. The cart, which has a pretty long line during the day, apparently is even more crowded at night, judging from the blurry shots Josh took with his iphone.

The food though is just as good, if not better, after you’ve had a few beer bongs worth of drinks! It was the perfect way to end a perfect day of eating.

Chicken and lamb over rice with white sauce and hot sauce

Chicken and lamb over rice with white sauce and hot sauce

Lan Zhou
144 East Broadway between Pike and Rutgers St.
New York, NY

Paris Sandwich
113 Mott St. between Hester and Canal St.
New York, NY

Di Palo’s Fine Foods
200 Grand St. between Mulberry and Mott St.
New York, NY

Lansdowne Road
599 10th Ave. between 43rd and 44th St.
New York, NY

Famous Halal Cart
Corner of 53rd St. and 6th Ave. (SE Corner during the day, SW Corner at night)
New York, NY

Quickie Recap: Lincoln Park

Friday, May 22nd, 2009 by virginia

We had some friends visiting from out of town this weekend who arrived late Friday night. We wandered along 9th Ave. for a bit looking for a place to grab a bite and a beer, and just catch up. We passed by Lincoln Park, which had its windows wide open and looked pretty laid back, so we decided to head in. It’s pretty much a dive bar with sticky tables and casual bar fare. My Sam Adams Summer Ale came out a bit flat, which was disappointing. Also disappointing was the chicken sandwich with buffalo sauce, which came on a stale hero. The buffalo sauce was too vinegary and not spicy enough.

Not so great buffalo chicken sandwich

Not so great buffalo chicken sandwich

Josh’s blackened cajun chicken sandwich was better, with a thick coating of spice, but still nothing to write home about. The fries were the standard shoestring frozen kind, similar to McDonalds, but at least they were hot.

Blackened cajun chicken sandwich

Blackened cajun chicken sandwich

Overall I might come back for a beer (hopefully one that is more carbonated), as the music was good (if a bit too loud) and there are some couches in front by the open windows to relax on, but I definitely won’t be back for the food.

Lincoln Park
867 9th Ave. between 56th and 57th St.
New York, NY

Lime Jungle

Friday, May 22nd, 2009 by virginia

DSCN8149

I got out of work a bit early on the Friday of Memorial Day weekend so I met up with Josh (who had the whole day off, lucky!) for a leisurely late lunch. I pass Lime Jungle every day on my way to work and it looked like a cute place so we decided to check it out. The restaurant is long and narrow but has a bright and cheerful jungle theme painted on the wall. Since we had a long weekend ahead of us, I was in a celebratory mood and opted to have a frozen strawberry margarita ($6). Unfortunately, this version was pretty artificial tasting and watery, which was disappointing because the restaurant offers many different tequilas and several flavors of margaritas, so I thought it would be one of their specialties.

Sadly watery frozen strawberry margarita

Sadly watery frozen strawberry margarita

I was craving chili nachos so we ordered nachos with seasoned ground beef. The nachos, served on four large tostadas, are not the messy pile that you find in most restaurants. These were carefully layered with beans, jalapenos and the seasoned ground beef, and then topped off with melted jack and cheddar cheese, lettuce and pico de gallo. Containers of sour cream were offered on the side. The tostadas weren’t sturdy enough to support the weight of the toppings, however, so I ended up eating them with a knife and fork. The flavors were good but the tostadas got soggy very quickly and everything fell apart.

"Nachos" with chili and cheese

"Nachos" with chili and cheese

We also opted for “Hell’s Kitchen Jalapenos” as our other appetizer. These were jalapeno poppers stuffed with cheddar cheese, breaded and deep fried. They also came with lettuce and pico de gallo, and a sauce that is described as “creamy cilantro” but tasted more like ranch dressing.

"Hell's Kitchen Jalapenos"

"Hell's Kitchen Jalapenos"

These poppers were served hot and crispy but tasted fairly standard.

Jalapeno popper cheesy innards

Jalapeno popper cheesy innards

For our main course, we split an order of chicken fajitas ($9.99). The chicken came on a sizzling platter with grilled onions, peppers and melted cheese.

Chicken fajitas with onions, peppers and cheese

Chicken fajitas with onions, peppers and cheese

The flour tortillas were served on the side in a wooden salad bowl with lettuce and pico de gallo. We added a small container of guacamole for an extra $1.00. The chicken was tender and the grilled peppers and onions were very fresh tasting. I just wish they gave us more than three small tortillas, as we had a lot more filling left over that we ended up eating with a knife and fork.

Fixings for the chicken fajitas

Fixings for the chicken fajitas

Overall I found Lime Jungle to have a slightly watered down version of Mexican food (or at least the Americanized version of Mexican food), as I think they try to offer “healthier” options (lots of salads, whole burritos, etc.). The taste of the food was very clean and it was significantly less greasy than some other places; I left feeling full but not disgustingly bloated like I usually do after gorging on nachos and fried foods. But if you’re craving the cheesy/gooey/salty/spicy aspect of Mexican food, this isn’t that kind of place.

Lime Jungle
803 9th Ave. between 53rd and 54th St.
New York, NY

Reade Street Pub & Kitchen

Thursday, May 21st, 2009 by virginia

Reade Street Pub & Kitchen in Tribeca is my absolute favorite bar in NYC. It’s one of those typically divey bar and grills that offers cheap drinks and solid food. The main draw for us is that on Thursday nights and every other Saturday nights, Reade Street features live music via talented guitarist Chris Decker. Chris plays an eclectic mix of classic rock and some more contemporary songs. He’s got a great sense of humor and tolerates it when drunk people (i.e., Josh) shout requests at him nonstop. If he doesn’t know the song, he makes an effort to learn it for the next time, and if you’re brave and/or drunk enough, he’ll also invite you up to sing with him. We love his expansive repertoire of Beatles songs, and his version of “Rocket Man,” which, depending on how many drinks he’s had, can range from classic (a la Elton John) to dramatic (a la William Shatner/Stewie Griffin).

Chris in action on Thursday night

Chris in action on Thursday night

But back to the food. Reade Street offers typical bar menu items (nachos, buffalo wings, burgers, sandwiches, etc.) but executes them very well. Josh’s standard order is the pub burger with swiss cheese and bacon. While the burger obviously doesn’t compare to some of the city’s greatest (i.e., Corner Bistro, Shake Shack), it gets a nice char and is well seasoned.

Pub burger with swiss cheese and bacon

Pub burger with swiss cheese and bacon

They have a tendency to overcook it a bit, so a medium rare order usually ends up being closer to medium. It’s still really juicy though, and I’ve burned my hand many times on the juices that run out when you bite into it.

Pub burger with swiss cheese and bacon

Autopsy shot

My grilled chicken club is seriously the best I’ve had anywhere. I hesitate to order chicken/turkey clubs at an unfamiliar place because they’re usually just dry and mealy, but somehow the kitchen at Reade Street manages to keep the chicken breast completely moist. Their version is a standard triple decker sandwich piled high with grilled chicken, bacon, lettuce, tomato and red onion. Mayo is not necessary, but I love mayo so I slather it on liberally (yet another reason why I have a fat belly). Both the sandwich and the burger come with a side of fries (you can substitute with salad) that are made from real potatoes and are the perfect thickness – not too thin and not too fat.

The best chicken club sandwich

The best chicken club sandwich

When Josh and I lived in Battery Park City, we would stay for hours at Reade Street listening to Chris, going through multiple pitchers of Reade Street Ale (only $9 a pitcher!) and then stumbling home. It was a nice walk and gave us a chance to sober up on the way. Now that we live uptown we have to take the train, which just isn’t the same, but it’s still worth the trip. Reade Street is really an awesome place. I’m almost hesitant to give it such a great review as it’s crowded enough, but then again, it’s not really a big secret. It’s popular among the after work crowd as it’s a stone’s throw away from the Citi building and the World Financial Center. It’s also a hangout for New York Law School and BMCC students. The bartender is quite a character (and is friends with former Mets players whom she encourages to come hang out!), and the waitresses are always friendly. We can stay there for hours eating and drinking pitcher after pitcher until we can drink no more, and somehow the bill always comes down to less than $25/person, including tax and a generous tip.

Cheap pitchers, cheap food, and crayons. What more can you ask for?

Cheap pitchers, cheap food, and crayons. What more can you ask for?

Reade Street Pub & Kitchen
135 Reade St. between Hudson and Greenwich
New York, NY

Yum Yum Bangkok

Wednesday, May 20th, 2009 by virginia

DSCN8096

One of the best deals during lunch is Yum Yum Bangkok, located on 9th Ave between 45th and 46th St. For whatever reason, there are three Yum Yums on that stretch of the street and I think they’re related since they all offer the same lunch special. We always go to the same one though, the one that’s the furthest north on the street. It’s a bit of a hike from my office near Rockefeller Center, but totally worth the trip. Any entree order comes with a choice of two starters, so you can essentially get a three course lunch for under $10. Starter options include soup, salad, spring rolls, dumplings or a drink (soda, thai iced coffee/tea). Even though the appetizers are a bit small, Yum Yum does not skimp on the entree size; I can stuff my face and still have enough left over for lunch the next day.

I met up with my lunch buddy Rodney who works nearby and off we went. The walk over goes much quicker when you have good company to chat with on the way. Rodney chose to start with the coconut chicken soup and spring rolls. You can definitely taste the coconut milk in the soup and the rich flavor makes even the small serving hard to get through. The mushrooms and scallions on top are a nice touch, but don’t add much to the flavor.

DSCN8093

Spring rolls

I also opted for the spring rolls, which are are approximately the size of my index finger and come two to an order. They always arrive freshly fried and piping hot, and the accompanying sweet chili sauce (which tastes a bit like duck sauce from Chinese restaurants) allows for multiple double dips. I usually go for the spicy shrimp soup (which has a tart lemongrass flavor) as my other starter, but with the weather warming up I decided to try the thai iced coffee, something I’ve never had before. I was expecting something a bit more exotic but this tasted like a Starbucks frappuccino that comes out of the bottle. It was sweet and rich and just fine, but nothing exciting. I’ll have to try the thai iced tea next time.

My Thai iced coffee and Rodney's coconut chicken soup

My Thai iced coffee and Rodney's coconut chicken soup

For our entrees, Rodney had beef with peanut sauce and I went with my standard chicken pad thai. I have to be honest – I don’t really like thai curries. I know there are many different kinds of curries, as curry is really just a term for a mix of spices, but I still haven’t found a thai curry that I enjoy, and I’ve tried a lot of them. I love Indian curries, Japanese curries and Malaysian curries, but for some reason, thai curries just don’t do it for me. I think maybe it’s the abundance of coconut milk or lemongrass but I don’t really know. Rodney enjoyed his dish though, and they gave him plenty of rice to soak up all the sauce.

Beef with peanut sauce

Beef with peanut sauce

My pad thai was delicious as always, although it’s probably not the most authentic version you can find in the city. It comes with a lot of chicken pieces though, and also strips of dried bean curd and scrambled eggs throughout. I love the fresh bean sprouts and julienned carrots they give you on the side. You can mix them in last minute (or leave them out altogether if you don’t like bean sprouts) and they retain their crunch. A squeeze of lemon over the whole thing really brings the dish together.

Chicken pad thai

Chicken pad thai

The pacing of the meal is quick, since most people have to get back to work within their lunch hour, but you never feel rushed. The service is prompt and attentive; our water glasses never get below half full. If you have time for dessert, they offer scoops of green tea or coconut ice cream for just $1. They call it a summer special but it’s available every time I go. Lunch for two, including tax and over 20% tip, came out to just $18. How can you go wrong?

Yum Yum Bangkok
650 9th Ave. between 45th and 46th St.
New York, NY

Oyishi

Tuesday, May 19th, 2009 by virginia

We recently moved to the Columbus Circle/Lincoln Square area and are still exploring the vast culinary options available in this neighborhood. We’ve tried a few restaurants in Hells Kitchen and are always searching for good places to order in from. We’ve only had one takeout menu slipped under our door so far, however, and figured that we would give it a shot. According to the menu, Oyishi offers standard Japanese food and sushi but there are lots of choices and pre-set combination plates that appear to be great deals.

We selected Special Roll Combo F ($11.95), which included a spicy tuna roll, a salmon avocado roll and a house special roll (a “jumbo” roll with salmon, tuna, yellowtail, white tuna, red snapper, crunch and tobiko). It also came with a choice of soup or salad. Our next selection was the all day sushi roll special, which is a choice of any two rolls for $6.66 or any three rolls for $8.99 and also includes a choice of soup or salad. The list of rolls to choose from doesn’t include any “deluxe” options, but all standard rolls are available. We went with a tuna roll, yellowtail with scallion, and white tuna with cucumber. Lastly, we decided to try a hot item and ordered a chicken katsu kitchen platter that is served with rice and salad ($6.25).

The delivery came pretty quickly, arriving in approximately 30 minutes. We opted for miso soups with our roll combinations, and those arrived still hot, which is a definite plus.

Still hot miso soups

Still hot miso soups

The chicken katsu was warm but the coating was no longer crunchy, something to be expected from delivered fried food. It had a nice peppery flavor but lost points for the prepackaged manufactured katsu sauce that came in foil packets. The accompanying salad was just iceberg, a single slice of cucumber, a single slice of tomato and, oddly, a wedge of lime. The dressing was standard ginger but they didn’t even give us enough to cover the small salad. Maybe I should have squeezed the lime wedge over the rest of the lettuce?

Chicken katsu with prepackaged katsu sauce and a side salad with ginger dressing

Chicken katsu with prepackaged katsu sauce and a side salad with ginger dressing.

The main event for us was the sushi. If there were just one food that Josh could eat for the rest of his life, it would be sushi. As such, he takes his fish pretty seriously and freshness is obviously a huge issue. Overall, the rolls were decent.

DSCN8082

House special roll (top), spicy tuna roll (left), salmon avocado roll (right)

Yellowtail is my favorite fish and this version tasted pretty fresh. The scallion, usually just side note, was nicely crisp and brightened up the flavor of the roll. The tuna and salmon were a bit pale but tasted ok. Josh really didn’t like the white tuna, however, and found it to be too stringy.

DSCN8083

White tuna cucumber roll (left), tuna roll (top), yellowtail scallion roll (bottom)

Our biggest complaint was that the soy sauce was too sweet – kind of an oxymoron. At first we thought the sushi rice had too much sugar but when we tasted each component individually, the sauce proved to be the culprit.

The verdict: meh. Not bad, and certainly not the worst sushi we’ve ever had, but that’s not exactly a ringing endorsement. It was just slightly better than average. The prices, however, were very reasonable, and in fact, it would be a great Midtown Lunch place if it weren’t just out of bounds on 46th St. between 8th and 9th Aves. There are lots of combo specials during lunch that are well under the $10 limit. For me and Josh, however, I think we’ll be checking out some other Japanese restaurants in our delivery range.

Oyishi
374 West 46th St. between 8th and 9th Ave.
New York, NY

Sunrise Delicatessen

Tuesday, May 19th, 2009 by virginia

DSCN8064

Sunrise is pretty much a generic midtown deli but it offers a quick and reliable sandwich for those days when you don’t have time to linger over lunch. It’s located right across the street from Josh’s office and therefore makes it a convenient go-to place. We usually split two sandwiches – turkey and swiss on a roll with lettuce, tomato and honey mustard, and “The Godfather”, which is a huge Italian hero (salami, ham, provolone) with roasted peppers, lettuce and tomato. The honey mustard though is the thick gooey kind that packs a punch on your sinuses if you eat too much at once, and therefore I love it.

Turkey and swiss on a roll with honey mustard sauce on the side.

Turkey and swiss on a roll with honey mustard sauce on the side.

One of the best features of The Godfather is the bread that it’s served on, which is a quintessential chewy Italian bread with sesame seeds sturdy enough to contain the sandwich contents but not stale or too tough to bite through easily. A container of oil and vinegar on the side, drizzled on right before eating so that the sandwich doesn’t get soggy, is the perfect complement.

The Godfather

The Godfather

The Godfather, which includes a side of potato chips (sometimes slightly stale but always better than no chips at all, especially if you’re feeling a bit peckish), is really a great deal at $7.25 (the turkey and swiss sandwich clocks in at $7.50). If you didn’t have two fat bellies like us, you could definitely save a half for dinner and still be satisfied.

Sunrise Delicatessen
575 7th Ave. between 40th and 41st St.
New York, NY

Crisp

Monday, May 18th, 2009 by virginia

When Josh’s coworkers suggested picking up lunch from Crisp I was excited. Not having fulfilled my falafel craving on Sunday, I was eager to try Crisp’s version after reading some good reviews on the Midtown Lunch blog. Midtown Lunch is one of my favorite sites and has steered me towards many great meals. I love the blog’s philosophy of finding cheap, delicious and satisfying lunches in the giant tourist trap that is midtown. Zach enjoyed Crisp’s Mexican falafel so of course I had to follow suit. Boy was I disappointed.

The falafel ball itself was standard, a fact that I was already warned about. It was comparable to the falafel balls from Moshe’s truck – good, not great. The Mexican is also supposed to contain cilantro pesto, avocado, corn, salsa and nachos with jalapeno dressing. My first impression was that the sandwich was extremely dry; the tiny container of salsa did nothing to rectify that issue. The cilantro pesto was not spread evenly throughout the sandwich so some bites would be surprisingly overwhelming in cilantro flavor. I tasted no avocado at all. And what the heck is “nachos with jalapeno dressing?” I found two slices pickled jalapenos on top, the kind that come from a jar and are standard on any plate of nachos, but there were no tortilla chips or cheese or anything resembling “nachos.” Am I missing something here? But the worst offender for me was the corn, which tasted like it was dumped straight from a can and had that chewy, tough quality to it. I guess for a place that touts how “fresh” its ingredients are, I was expecting fresh corn bursting with sweet goodness. I should have known better, especially since corn is such a seasonal ingredient and fresh corn isn’t available year round. I eventually tried to pick out as many of the kernals as I could but there were a lot of them and the tinny flavor of the canned corn had already permeated throughout the sandwich.

The Mexican

The Mexican

I did like the packaging of the sandwich though, as it was contained in a cardboard sleeve that prevented the sandwich from falling apart. Messiness is something I usually can’t avoid when eating falafel, and I was able to keep from spilling on myself this time. I kept the cardboard sleeve on the whole time and just pushed the sandwich up from the bottom, like one does with an apple pie from McDonalds.

Overall I was disappointed with the Mexican, but I did have a bite of Josh’s Parisian sandwich that I thought was much tastier. You really have to like goat cheese to enjoy that sandwich though, as it was completely smothered with it.

The Parisian

The Parisian

His coworkers tried the Athenian and the African, and both of them enjoyed theirs as well. I guess mine was a fluke? I’m not going to write this place off based on one bad sandwich experience, as I can see the potential in their different flavor combinations. And while the corn was bad, the whole wheat pita was soft and fluffy and the other ingredients were nicely seasoned. It is pretty pricey for a falafel sandwich, though the Mexican is one of the cheapest at $7.75; the Parisian is $9.75. It was a very filling lunch, however, so I think it could be worth the price. I’ll have to sample some of the other sandwiches before I pass final judgment on this place.

Crisp (multiple locations)
110 West 40th St. between 6th Ave. and Broadway
New York, NY

Kefi

Sunday, May 17th, 2009 by virginia

IMG_3302_1

We made a reservation at Kefi on opentable.com for 7 pm. As usual, we were running a bit behind schedule and called the restaurant to say we would be about 15 minutes late. The response was, “no problem, we’ll see you when you get here.” A few unexpected street closings on Amsterdam meant that we showed up 10 minutes after our stated 15-minute delay. We apologized to the hostess upon our arrival, and she again said it was not a problem, and that that our table would be ready in a few minutes.

We stood by the bar and surveyed the room, commenting on the décor and talking about what we wanted order when the time came. A few minutes soon turned into half an hour, and it was almost 8 pm by the time we were seated. Ok, I know that we were late for our reservation, but they gave no indication that it was an issue, or that they had given away our table. And on our trip to the dining room in the basement, we noticed several empty tables along the way. I thought maybe they were waiting to give us a more intimate table in the basement, since we noted when we made our reservation that it was our first anniversary celebration, but there was no acknowledgement of that note by anyone. In fact, our server was surprised when she overheard us saying it was our anniversary to the table next to us at the end of our meal. Not that I really expected anything out of it, but it just made our long wait all the more puzzling.

But on to more important things: the food. As we perused the menu, we were brought a bucket of bread to munch on. We like to say that the bread is a good indicator of a restaurant; we’ve generally found that the better the bread, the better the restaurant, and vice versa. This version was pretty good – a rustic bread that was served warm and had a sturdy, crispy crust. Even better was the olive oil to go with it – bright green and fruity.

Good bread and even better olive oil

Good bread and even better olive oil

We ordered two glasses of retsina to start. Retsina is something that Josh and I have debated about since our honeymoon. The only time we tried a retsina was our first night in Athens, at a random taverna in the Plaka area. I remembered the retsina being like a refreshing but acidic white wine, and Josh remembers disliking it but not remembering how it tasted. Basically, we both ended up sick that night, and I attributed it to the food while Josh connected it with the retsina. The version we had at Kefi was nothing like either of us remembered. This retsina had a very strong pine taste, something that I associate with gin, which is my least favorite liquor. Josh loves gin, but apparently hates gin-tasting wine. Either way, I don’t think we’ll be drinking retsina again, unless someone can recommend a good one! We also ordered a bottle of wine that was much better on our palates – a medium bodied, fruity and spicy red (as described on the wine list, I don’t remember the name of the wine).

Before coming to the restaurant, I looked at the menu online and had a hard time deciding what I wanted; everything sounded to my liking, and prices topped out at $16.95. After much discussion, we eventually decided on the Greek spreads and the grilled octopus to start, a second course of the flat pasta with braised rabbit to share, and the grilled branzino and grilled lamb chops ($22.95, a special) for our main courses.

The spreads, which consisted of melitzanosalata, tzatziki, revithia and taramosalata, were delicious. The eggplant had a subtle smoky flavor, the yogurt very bright and garlicky, the chickpea bursting with roasted red pepper flavor, and the caviar spread not too fishy. And all the spreads were doused with a healthy sprinkling of that delicious olive oil. The accompanying pita was good too – nicely grilled and still warm; I just wish there was more of it (I am a bread/carb fiend).

Selection of spreads

Selection of spreads

The other first course, the grilled octopus, was a mixed bag. The plate came with two tentacles; Josh started on the first while I worked my way through the spreads. He passed the plate to me so I could have the second tentacle, and he was amazed when I raved about how tender it was. I gave him a bite and he commented that his piece was much tougher, which is surprising that there could be such a difference in preparation on the same plate. Either way, the bean salad underneath, comprising of black-eyed peas and chickpeas, was a good lemony and garlicky accompaniment.

Grilled octopus appetizer

Grilled octopus appetizer

Our second course of flat pasta with pulled braised rabbit was not what I expected and seemed more Italian to me than Greek. The tender pieces of rabbit and pasta were dressed in a creamy tomato sauce and topped with a crispy layer of cheese. Fresh basil brought out the Italian side of the dish, and the glazed onions, while delicious on their own, seemed a bit of out place. Based on the menu description, I was expecting something a bit more earthy in flavor, though overall the dish was still tasty. My main complaint, however, was that the dish wasn’t very hot. Warm, yes, but not brown and bubbling as one would expect from a pasta that is served in a gratin dish and covered in cheese.

Flat pasta with pulled braised rabbit

Flat pasta with pulled braised rabbit

Our main courses did not suffer from the same fate, as they were brought hot and still sizzling to our table. Josh’s branzino, a fish that he loves to order in any restaurant, was served as two fillets, cooked perfectly and had addictively crispy skin.

Perfectly grilled branzino

Perfectly grilled branzino

My grilled lamb chops, also a dish I find hard to resist at any restaurant, came as four separated chops from a rack, were very well seasoned and cooked rare to order. The accompany rice mixed with spinach was a bit puzzling, however, as the rice seemed firm yet gluey. It was not a dish that I’ve tried before, and not something that I really enjoyed texture-wise.

Delicious grilled lamb chops

Delicious grilled lamb chops

We were too full for dessert (plus we knew we had cake waiting for us back at our apartment) but had some after-dinner drinks. I ordered a frappe while Josh had an espresso. The frappe, my first since I had a bad version at the airport in Athens, was creamy, frothy and cold, with just a hint of sweetness. It was a good way to finish off the meal.

Refreshing frappe

Josh's espresso and my refreshing frappe

Overall we had a mixed impression about the restaurant. Aside from the long wait, the service was frantic. While our server was attentive and observant (for example, she noticed our table was wobbly, fetched a piece of cardboard and then got down on her hands and knees underneath the cramped table to fix the wobbling), it seemed like we couldn’t get through each course fast enough. The runners were bringing our next course before we had finished the previous course, and given the tiny table and lack of real estate for our plates, we felt obliged to relinquish our dishes before we were totally done eating. There were absolutely no breathers in between courses, and I felt like if I put my fork down for one second someone would swoop in and take my plate, which is what happened during the pasta course. Just to give the people who know us an idea of how quickly we were eating, we got through less than half the bottle of wine during the three savory courses; for that amount of food, we can usually go through two bottles of wine between the two of us, easily. We ended up nursing the other half of the bottle before starting our after-dinner drinks, and had to ask for some extra bread to soak up the wine.

Despite the shortcomings, Kefi is absolutely a place that I’ll come back to, just for the food. Reading previous reviews made me aware of the fast pacing, the cramped-ness and the loudness of the restaurant, so those were things that I expected, even if I didn’t enjoy them. The food, however, exceeded my high expectations, and there are still a lot of things on the menu that I didn’t get to try. The prices at Kefi are also extremely reasonable. Our dinner, with two appetizers, a pasta course, two main courses (including the pricier dinner special), along with two glasses of retsina, a bottle of red wine and two coffee drinks, came out to about $170, including tax and a generous tip.

Kefi
505 Columbus Ave. between 84th and 85th St.
New York, NY